Each Camera Signature is the colour, tone and shooting habits of real photographs, as numbers. The tone histograms share one scale, so their heights can be compared.
D5100
1000 photos by 120 photographers
Colours
#221e20, 29%
#c2c2c1, 23%
#707179, 22%
#625835, 13%
#a7a052, 9%
#ad4d36, 5%
Tone
Photographs, matched
A fair comparison uses like for like: the filters below apply to every camera at once, so you are looking at the same light and the same field of view.
Average brightness 42%, contrast 84%, 3% of pixels clipped to black and 1% to white.
Tendencies
Warmthleans warm (0.29)
CoolWarm
Tintleans magenta (0.08)
GreenMagenta
Saturation24%
MutedVivid
How it is shot
ISOmedian 220
ISO 400 and under: 70%
ISO 800 – 3200: 29%
ISO 3200+: 1%
ISO 400 and under 70%
ISO 800 – 3200 29%
ISO 3200+ 1%
Aperturemedian f/5.6
f/2 and wider: 5%
f/2.1 – f/5.6: 57%
f/5.7 and narrower: 38%
f/2 and wider 5%
f/2.1 – f/5.6 57%
f/5.7 and narrower 38%
Focal length (35 mm equivalent)median 77 mm
Wide: 19%
Standard: 46%
Telephoto: 35%
Wide 19%
Standard 46%
Telephoto 35%
D5300
995 photos by 173 photographers
Colours
#27221e, 32%
#6e6860, 24%
#c4c2bf, 18%
#6e7832, 10%
#a15d33, 9%
#678abb, 7%
Tone
Shadows 45%Mids 39%Highlights 16%
Average brightness 40%, contrast 79%, 2% of pixels clipped to black and 1% to white.
Tendencies
Warmthleans warm (0.30)
CoolWarm
Tintleans magenta (0.06)
GreenMagenta
Saturation25%
MutedVivid
How it is shot
ISOmedian 200
ISO 400 and under: 76%
ISO 800 – 3200: 22%
ISO 3200+: 2%
ISO 400 and under 76%
ISO 800 – 3200 22%
ISO 3200+ 2%
Aperturemedian f/5.6
f/2 and wider: 9%
f/2.1 – f/5.6: 47%
f/5.7 and narrower: 44%
f/2 and wider 9%
f/2.1 – f/5.6 47%
f/5.7 and narrower 44%
Focal length (35 mm equivalent)median 64 mm
Wide: 26%
Standard: 46%
Each Signature draws on up to 1,000 of a camera’s newest photos, spread across as many photographers as possible. It reflects the photographers and their subjects as much as the camera.
Newer D5300 shoots brighter and faster; D5100 slightly cooler and darker
The two cameras give broadly similar photographs, both warm-leaning with vivid colour and a similar aperture habit. The clearest difference is in exposure: photographs from the D5300 sit lower in brightness and shutter speeds are faster, while the D5100 shows more shadow and midtone weight and slightly more telephoto framing. Most other measures are close enough that the choice should rest on handling and resolution rather than on the look of the pictures.
Based on 1,765 photographs by 183 photographers on Reflectr. Updated November 2026.
Tone
The D5300 has a mean brightness of 0.39 against 0.42 for the D5100, and it is darker than most cameras in the catalog, while the D5100 sits about typical. The D5100 has the higher contrast at 0.84 against 0.78, and more of its pixels are pure black at 3% against 2%.
Colour
Both are warm, with warmth at 0.3 on the D5300 and 0.29 on the D5100, and tint is nearly identical at 0.07 and 0.08. Saturation is slightly higher on the D5300 at 0.26 against 0.24, and both are more vivid than most cameras in the catalog.
Shutter
Median shutter speed is 1/250 s on the D5300 and 1/160 s on the D5100, so photographs from the D5300 more often freeze movement. Both cameras have the same fastest shutter of 1/4000 sec.
Framing
The D5100 leans slightly longer, with a median of 77 mm and 35% telephoto against 69 mm and 28% on the D5300. Standard framing is close at 46% and 47%, and the D5300 includes more wide shots at 25% against 19%.
Choose the D5100 ifyou prefer slightly higher contrast and a little more telephoto reach, and do not need the extra resolution.
Choose the D5300 ifyou want a 24.2 MP sensor and faster typical shutter speeds for moving subjects.