Side by side
The difference, in their photographs
Reading both sets of photographsEach Camera Signature is the colour, tone and shooting habits of real photographs, as numbers. The tone histograms share one scale, so their heights can be compared.
1000 photos by 120 photographers
Average brightness 42%, contrast 84%, 3% of pixels clipped to black and 1% to white.
1000 photos by 50 photographers
Average brightness 46%, contrast 77%, 1% of pixels clipped to black and 1% to white.
Each Signature draws on up to 1,000 of a camera’s newest photos, spread across as many photographers as possible. It reflects the photographers and their subjects as much as the camera.
A fair comparison uses like for like: the filters below apply to every camera at once, so you are looking at the same light and the same field of view.
8 differences marked
| Nikon D5100 | Nikon D300s | |
|---|---|---|
| Announced(differs) | 2011 | 2009 |
| Type | Interchangeable lens | Interchangeable lens |
| Sensor | CMOS | CMOS |
| Colour filter | Bayer | Bayer |
| Sensor size(differs) | 23.6 × 15.6 mm | 23.6 × 15.8 mm |
| Crop factor(differs) | 1.53× | 1.52× |
| Resolution(differs) | 16.2 MP | 12.3 MP |
| ISO(differs) | 100–6400 | 200–3200 |
| Extended ISO(differs) | 100–25600 | 100–6400 |
| Fastest shutter(differs) | 1/4000 sec | 1/8000 sec |
| Weight(differs) | 560 g | 938 g |
The difference, in their photographs
On Reflectr, photographs made with the Nikon D5100 lean warmer and more saturated, with a higher contrast and darker overall tone. Photographs from the Nikon D300s are brighter and higher-key, with a flatter contrast and a broader spread of shutter speeds and focal lengths. Tint and aperture habits are close between the two, so those are not where they part ways.
Based on 2,000 photographs by 165 photographers on Reflectr. Updated November 2026.